Charles Darwin
{{pp-semi|small=yes}}{{featured article}}{{for|other people of the same surname, and places and things named after Darwin|Darwin}}
The Mount, Shrewsbury>Mount House, Shrewsbury, Shropshire, England | 1882 | 19 | 2 | df=yes}}|death_place = Down House, Downe, Kent, England|residence = England|citizenship = | United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland>British|ethnicity = | natural history>Naturalist|workplaces = Royal Geographical Society|alma_mater = University of Edinburgh | University of Cambridgeacademic_advisors = Adam Sedgwick | John Stevens Henslownotable_students = |known_for = | The Voyage of the BeagleOn The Origin of SpeciesNatural selection|author_abbrev_bot = |author_abbrev_zoo = |influences =
Charles Lyell|influenced =
Thomas Henry HuxleyGeorge John Romanes |awards =
Royal Medal (1853)
Wollaston Medal (1859)
Copley Medal (1864)
Church of England, though Unitarianism>Unitarian family background, Agnostic after 1851.|signature = Darwinsig.png | Erasmus Darwin and a grandson of Josiah Wedgwood, and married his cousin Emma Darwin>Emma Wedgwood. }} | Charles Robert Darwin (February 12, 1809 – April 19, 1882) was an
English naturalist,{{Ref_label|A|I|none}} who realised and demonstrated that all
species of life have
evolved over time from
common ancestors through the process he called
natural selection.
(1) and now forms the basis of
modern evolutionary theory. In modified form, Darwin’s scientific discovery remains the foundation of
biology, as it provides a unifying
logical explanation for the
diversity of life.
(2)Darwin developed his interest in natural history while studying
medicine at
Edinburgh University, then
theology at
Cambridge.
(3) His
five-year voyage on the
Beagle established him as an eminent
geologist whose observations and theories supported
Charles Lyell’s
uniformitarian ideas, and publication of his
journal of the voyage made him famous as a popular author. Puzzled by the geographical distribution of wildlife and
fossils he collected on the voyage, Darwin investigated the
transmutation of species and conceived his theory of natural selection in 1838.
(4) Although he discussed his ideas with several naturalists, he needed time for extensive research and his geological work had priority.
(5) He was writing up his theory in 1858 when
Alfred Russel Wallace sent him an essay which described the same idea, prompting immediate joint publication of
both of their theories.
(6)His 1859 book
On the Origin of Species established evolution by
common descent as the dominant scientific explanation of diversification in nature. He examined
human evolution and
sexual selection in
The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex, followed by
The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals. His research on plants was published in a series of books, and in his final book, he examined
earthworms and their effect on soil.
(7)In recognition of Darwin’s pre-eminence, he was one of only five 19th century UK non-royal personages to be honoured by a state funeral,
(8) and was buried in
Westminster Abbey, close to
John Herschel and
Isaac Newton.
(9)Biography
Early life
{{details|Charles Darwin's education}}
missing image!
- Charles Darwin 1816.jpg -
The seven-year-old Charles Darwin in 1816, one year before his mother’s death.
Charles Robert Darwin was born in
Shrewsbury,
Shropshire, England on 12 February 1809 at his family home,
the Mount.
(10) He was the fifth of six children of wealthy society doctor and financier
Robert Darwin, and
Susannah Darwin (
née Wedgwood). He was the grandson of
Erasmus Darwin on his father’s side, and of
Josiah Wedgwood on his mother’s side. Both families were largely
Unitarian, though the Wedgwoods were adopting
Anglicanism. Robert Darwin, himself quietly a
freethinker, made a nod toward convention by having baby Charles
baptised in the Anglican Church. Nonetheless, Charles and his siblings attended the Unitarian chapel with their mother, and in 1817, Charles joined the day school, run by its preacher. In July of that year, when Charles was eight years old, his mother died. From September 1818, he joined his older brother
Erasmus attending the nearby Anglican
Shrewsbury School as a
boarder.
(11)Darwin spent the summer of 1825 as an apprentice doctor, helping his father treat the poor of Shropshire. In the autumn, he went with Erasmus to the
University of Edinburgh to study medicine, but was revolted by the brutality of
surgery and neglected his medical studies. He learned
taxidermy from
John Edmonstone, a freed black slave who had accompanied
Charles Waterton in the
South American
rainforest. Darwin often sat with this "very pleasant and intelligent man",
(12) and later recalled this as evidence against "ranking the so-called races of man as distinct species".
(13)In Darwin’s second year he joined the Plinian Society, a student group of
natural history enthusiasts,
(14) and assisted Dr.
Robert Edmund Grant’s investigations of the anatomy and life cycle of
marine animals in the
Firth of Forth. In March 1827 Darwin made a presentation to the Plinian of his own discovery that the black spores often found in
oyster shells were the eggs of a skate
leech.
(15) Grant expounded
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck’s
theory of evolution by
acquired characteristics, and the evolutionary ideas of Charles’s grandfather Erasmus which Darwin had recently read. Grant found evidence for
homology, the
radical theory that all animals have similar
organs which differ only in complexity, thus showing
common descent.
(16) Darwin was rather bored by
Robert Jameson’s natural history course which covered
geology including the debate between
Neptunism and
Plutonism. He learnt
classification of plants, and assisted with work on the extensive collections of the
University Museum, one of the largest museums in Europe at the time.
(17)The failure to pursue medical studies annoyed his father, who shrewdly enrolled him in a
Bachelor of Arts course at
Christ’s College, Cambridge to qualify as a clergyman and get a good income as an Anglican
parson.
(18) Darwin began the course in January 1828, but preferred
riding and
shooting to studying.
(19) With his cousin
Fox, he became engrossed in the popular craze for
beetle collecting and had some of his finds published in
Stevens' Illustrations of British entomology. He became a close friend and follower of botany professor
John Stevens Henslow, and met leading naturalists who saw scientific work as religious activity. His enthusiasm at Henslow’s botany course made him known to the
dons as “the man who walks with Henslow”.
(20) When exams drew near, Darwin focused on his studies and received private instruction from Henslow, becoming delighted by the language and logic of
William Paley's
Evidences of Christianity.
(21) In his finals in January 1831, Darwin performed well in
theology and scraped through in
classics,
mathematics and
physics, coming tenth out of a pass list of 178.
(22)Residential requirements kept Darwin at Cambridge until June. He studied Paley's
Natural Theology which made an
argument for divine design in nature, explaining
adaptation as God acting through laws of nature.
(23) He read
William Herschel's new book which described the highest aim of
natural philosophy as understanding these laws through
inductive reasoning based on observation, and
Alexander von Humboldt’s
Personal Narrative of scientific travels, and was inspired with "a burning zeal" to contribute. He planned to visit
Tenerife with some classmates after graduation to study natural history in the
tropics. In preparation, Darwin joined the geology course of the Reverend
Adam Sedgwick then went with him in the summer mapping strata in
Wales.
(24) After a fortnight with student friends at
Barmouth, he returned home to find a letter from Henslow recommending Darwin as a suitable (if unfinished) naturalist for the unpaid position of gentleman’s companion to
Robert FitzRoy, the captain of
HMS Beagle, which was to leave in four weeks on an expedition to chart the coastline of South America. His father objected to the planned two-year voyage, regarding it as a waste of time, but was persuaded by his brother-in-law,
Josiah WedgwoodJosiah WedgwoodThe voyage lasted almost five years and, as FitzRoy had intended, Darwin spent most of that time on land investigating geology and making natural history collections, while the
Beagle surveyed and charted coasts.
(26)(27) He had some expertise in geology, beetle collecting and marine invertebrates, but in all other areas was a novice and ably collected specimens for expert appraisal.
(28) Despite repeatedly suffering badly from seasickness while at sea,
(29) most of his zoology notes are about the sea creatures he dissected, and they start with
plankton collected in a calm spell.
(30) In
Brazil, Darwin was delighted by the
tropical forest.
(31) but detested the sight of
slavery.
(32) At
Punta Alta in
Patagonia he made a major find of fossils of huge extinct
mammals in cliffs beside modern seashells, indicating recent extinction with no signs of change in climate or catastrophe. He identified the little known
Megatherium, with bony armour which seemed to him like giant versions of the armour on local
armadillos. The finds brought great interest when they reached England.
(33) On rides with
gauchos into the interior to explore geology and collect more fossils he gained social, political and
anthropological insights into both native and colonial people at a time of revolution, and learnt that two types of
rhea had separate but overlapping territories.
(34)(35) Further south he saw stepped plains of shingle and seashells as
raised beaches showing a series of elevations. He read Lyell’s second volume and accepted its view of “centres of creation” of species, but his discoveries and theorising challenged Lyell's ideas of smooth continuity and of extinction of species.
(36)(37)HMS Beagle by Conrad Martens.jpg -
Three Fuegians on board, who had been seized during the
first Beagle voyage around February 1830 and spent a year in England, were taken back to
Tierra del Fuego as missionaries. Darwin found them friendly and civilised, yet their relatives seemed “miserable, degraded savages”, as different as wild from domesticated animals.
(38) To Darwin the difference showed cultural advances, not racial inferiority. Unlike his scientist friends, he now thought there was no unbridgeable gap between humans and animals.
(39) A year on, the mission had been abandoned. The Fuegian they'd named
Jemmy Button lived like the other natives, had a wife, and had no wish to return to England.
(40)Darwin experienced an earthquake in
Chile and saw signs that the land had just been raised, including
mussel-beds stranded above high tide. High in the
Andes he saw seashells, and several fossil trees that had grown on a sand beach. He theorised that as the land rose,
oceanic islands sank, and
coral reefs round them grew to form
atolls.
(41)(42)On the
Galápagos Islands Darwin noted that
mockingbirds differed depending on which island they came from.
(43) He also heard that local Spaniards could tell from their appearance on which island
tortoises originated.
(44)In Australia, the
marsupial rat-kangaroo and the
platypus seemed so unusual that Darwin thought it was almost as though two distinct Creators had been at work.
(45) He found the
Aborigines "good-humoured & pleasant", and noted their depletion by European settlement.
(46) The
Beagle investigated the formation of the atolls of the
Cocos (Keeling) Islands, and the survey supported Darwin's idea.
(47) Darwin's
Journal was eventually rewritten as a separate third volume, on natural history.
(48)In
Cape Town Darwin and FitzRoy met
John Herschel, who had recently written to Lyell about that “mystery of mysteries”, the origin of species.
(49) When organising his notes as the ship sailed home, Darwin wrote that if his growing suspicions about the mockingbirds, the tortoises and the
Falkland Island Fox were correct, “such facts undermine the stability of Species”, then cautiously added “would” before “undermine”.
(50) He later wrote that such facts “seemed to me to throw some light on the origin of species”.
(51)Inception of Darwin’s evolutionary theory
{{details|Inception of Darwin's theory}}
missing image!
- Charles Darwin by G. Richmond.jpg -
While still a young man, Charles Darwin joined the scientific élite.
While Darwin was still on the voyage,
Henslow fostered his former pupil’s reputation by giving selected naturalists access to the fossil specimens and a pamphlet of Darwin’s geological letters.
(52) When the
Beagle returned on 2 October 1836, Darwin was a celebrity in scientific circles. After visiting his home in Shrewsbury and seeing relatives, Darwin hurried to
Cambridge to see Henslow, who advised on finding naturalists available to describe and catalogue the collections, and agreed to take on the botanical specimens. Darwin’s father organised investments, enabling his son to be a self-funded
gentleman scientist, and an excited Darwin went round the
London institutions being fêted and seeking experts to describe the collections. Zoologists had a huge backlog of work, and there was a danger of specimens just being left in storage.
(53)An eager
Charles Lyell met Darwin for the first time on 29 October and soon introduced him to the up-and-coming anatomist
Richard Owen, who had the facilities of the
Royal College of Surgeons at his disposal to work on the fossil bones collected by Darwin. Owen’s surprising results included gigantic extinct
sloths including a near complete skeleton of the unknown
Scelidotherium, a
hippopotamus-sized
rodent-like skull named
Toxodon resembling a giant
capybara, and armour fragments from a huge armadillo (
Glyptodon), as Darwin had initially surmised.
(54) These extinct creatures were closely related to living species in South America.
(55)In mid-December, Darwin moved to Cambridge to organise work on his collections and rewrite his
Journal.
(56) He wrote his first paper, showing that the South American landmass was slowly rising, and with Lyell’s enthusiastic backing read it to the
Geological Society of London on 4 January 1837. On the same day, he presented his mammal and bird specimens to the
Zoological Society. The ornithologist
John Gould soon revealed that the Galapagos birds that Darwin had thought a mixture of
blackbirds, “
gros-beaks” and
finches, were, in fact, twelve
separate species of finches. On 17 February 1837, Darwin was elected to the Council of the Geographical Society, and in his presidential address, Lyell presented Owen’s findings on Darwin’s fossils, stressing geographical continuity of species as supporting his
uniformitarian ideas.
(57)On 6 March 1837, Darwin moved to London to be close to this work, and joined the social whirl around scientists and
savants such as
Charles Babbage, who thought that God preordained life by
natural laws rather than
ad hoc miraculous creations. Darwin lived near his
freethinking brother
Erasmus, who was part of this
Whig circle and whose close friend the writer
Harriet Martineau promoted the ideas of
Thomas Malthus underlying the Whig “
Poor Law reforms” aimed at discouraging the poor from breeding beyond available food supplies.
John Herschel’s description of the origin of new species as the "mystery of mysteries" was widely discussed. Medical men even joined
Grant in endorsing
transmutation of species, a
radical idea which Darwin’s scientist friends rejected as an incorrect idea which endangered social order.
(58)missing image!
- Darwin tree.png -
In mid-July 1837 Darwin started his first notebook on Transmutation of Species, his “B” notebook, and on page 36 wrote “I think” above his first sketch of an evolutionary tree.
Gould revealed that the Galapagos
mockingbirds from different islands were separate species, not just varieties, and the “
wrens” were yet another species of finches. Darwin had not labelled his finch specimens by island, but from the notes of others on the
Beagle, including FitzRoy, he worked out that there were distinct species on each island. The zoologist
Thomas Bell showed that the
Galápagos tortoises were native to the islands.
(59) By mid-March, Darwin was speculating in his
Red Notebook on the possibility that "one species does change into another" to explain the geographical distribution of species both living and extinct.
(60) In his “B” notebook begun in mid-July his novel ideas of transmutation discarded
Lamarck's independent
lineages progressing to higher forms, and saw life as
genealogical branching of a single
evolutionary tree, in which "It is absurd to talk of one animal being higher than another".
(61)Overwork, illness, and marriage
As well as launching into this intensive study of
transmutation, Darwin became mired in more work. While still rewriting his
Journal, he took on editing and publishing the expert reports on his collections, and with Henslow’s help obtained a Treasury grant of
£1,000 to sponsor this multi-volume
Zoology of the Voyage of H.M.S. Beagle. He agreed to unrealistic dates for this and for a book on
South American Geology supporting Lyell’s ideas. Darwin finished writing his
Journal around 20 June 1837 just as
Queen Victoria came to the throne, but then had its proofs to correct.
(62)Darwin’s health suffered from the pressure. On 20 September 1837, he had “an uncomfortable palpitation of the heart", and his doctors urged him to "knock off all work" and live in the country for a few weeks. He went to Shrewsbury then on to visit his Wedgwood relatives at
Maer Hall, but found them too eager for tales of his travels to give him much rest. His charming, intelligent, and cultured cousin
Emma Wedgwood, nine months older than Darwin, was nursing his invalid aunt. His uncle
Jos pointed out an area of ground where cinders had disappeared under
loam and suggested that this might have been the work of
earthworms. This inspired a talk which Darwin gave to the Geological Society on 1 November, the first demonstration of the role of earthworms in
soil formation.
(63)William Whewell pushed Darwin to take on the duties of Secretary of the Geological Society. After first declining this extra work, he accepted the post in March 1838.
(64) Despite the grind of writing and editing the
Beagle reports, remarkable progress was made on transmutation. Darwin took every opportunity to question expert naturalists and, unconventionally, people with practical experience such as farmers and
pigeon fanciers.
(65) Over time his research drew on information from his relatives and children, the family butler, neighbours, colonists and former shipmates.
(66) He included mankind in his speculations from the outset, and on seeing an
ape in the zoo on 28 March 1838 noted its child-like behaviour.
(67)The strain took its toll, and by June he was being laid up for days on end with stomach problems, headaches and heart symptoms.
(68) For the rest of his life, he was repeatedly incapacitated with episodes of stomach pains, vomiting, severe
boils, palpitations, trembling and other symptoms, particularly during times of stress, such as when attending meetings or dealing with controversy over his theory. The cause of
Darwin’s illness was unknown during his lifetime, and attempts at treatment had little success. Recent attempts at diagnosis have suggested
Chagas disease caught from insect bites in South America,
Ménière’s disease, or various psychological illnesses as possible causes, without any conclusive results.
(69)On 23 June 1838, he took a break from the pressure of work and went “geologising” in Scotland. He visited
Glen Roy in glorious weather to see the parallel “roads” cut into the hillsides at three heights. He thought that these were marine
raised beaches: they were later shown to have been shorelines of a
proglacial lake.
(70)Fully recuperated, he returned to Shrewsbury in July. Used to jotting down daily notes on animal breeding, he scrawled rambling thoughts about career and prospects on two scraps of paper, one with columns headed
“Marry” and
“Not Marry”. Advantages included “constant companion and a friend in old age ... better than a dog anyhow”, against points such as “less money for books” and “terrible loss of time.”
(71) Having decided in favour, he discussed it with his father, then went to visit Emma on 29 July 1838. He did not get around to proposing, but against his father’s advice he mentioned his ideas on transmutation.
(72)Continuing his research in London, Darwin’s wide reading now included the sixth edition of
Malthus’s An Essay on the Principle of Population{{Quotation|In October 1838, that is, fifteen months after I had begun my systematic enquiry, I happened to read for amusement Malthus on Population, and being well prepared to appreciate the struggle for existence which everywhere goes on from long-continued observation of the habits of animals and plants, it at once struck me that under these circumstances favourable variations would tend to be preserved, and unfavourable ones to be destroyed. The result of this would be the formation of new species. Here, then, I had at last got a theory by which to work...
(73) }}Malthus asserted that unless human population is kept in check, it increases in a
geometrical progression and soon exceeds food supply in what is known as a
Malthusian catastrophe.
(74) Darwin was well prepared to see at once that this also applied to
de Candolle’s “warring of the species” of plants and the struggle for existence among wildlife, explaining how numbers of a species kept roughly stable. As species always breed beyond available resources, favourable variations would make organisms better at surviving and passing the variations on to their offspring, while unfavourable variations would be lost. This would result in the formation of new species.
(75) On 28 September 1838 he noted this insight, describing it as a kind of wedging, forcing adapted structures into gaps in the economy of nature as weaker structures were thrust out.
(76)missing image!
- Emma Darwin.jpg -
Charles chose to marry his cousin, Emma Wedgwood.
On 11 November, he returned to Maer and proposed to Emma, once more telling her his ideas. She accepted, then in exchanges of loving letters she showed how she valued his openness, but her upbringing as a very devout
Anglican led her to express fears that his lapses of faith could endanger her hopes to meet in the afterlife.
(77) While he was house-hunting in London, bouts of illness continued and Emma wrote urging him to get some rest, almost prophetically remarking “So don’t be ill any more my dear Charley till I can be with you to nurse you.” He found what they called “Macaw Cottage” (because of its gaudy interiors) in
Gower Street, then moved his “museum” in over Christmas. The marriage was arranged for 24 January 1839, but the Wedgwoods set the date back. On the 24th, Darwin was honoured by being elected as
Fellow of the Royal Society.
(78)On 29 January 1839, Darwin and Emma Wedgwood were married at Maer in an Anglican ceremony arranged to suit the Unitarians, then immediately caught the train to London and their new home.
(79)Preparing the theory of natural selection for publication
{{details|Development of Darwin's theory}}Darwin now had the framework of his theory of
natural selection “by which to work”,
(80) as his “prime hobby”.
(81) His research subsequently included
animal husbandry and extensive experiments with plants, finding evidence that species were not fixed and investigating many detailed ideas to refine and substantiate his theory.
(82) When FitzRoy’s
Narrative was published in May 1839, Darwin’s
Journal and Remarks (
The Voyage of the Beagle) as the third volume was such a success that later that year it was published on its own.
(83)Early in 1842, Darwin sent a letter about his ideas to
Lyell, who was dismayed that his ally now denied “seeing a beginning to each crop of species”. In May, Darwin’s book on
coral reefs was published after more than three years of work, and he then wrote a “pencil sketch” of his theory.
(84) To escape the pressures of London, the family moved to rural
Down House in November.
(85) On 11 January 1844 Darwin mentioned his theorising to the botanist
Joseph Dalton Hooker, writing with melodramatic humour “it is like confessing a murder”.
(86)(87) To his relief, Hooker replied “There may in my opinion have been a series of productions on different spots, & also a gradual change of species. I shall be delighted to hear how you think that this change may have taken place, as no presently conceived opinions satisfy me on the subject.”
(88)missing image!
- Darwins Thinking Path.JPG -
At Down House, Darwin took exercise on his “Thinking Path”.
By July, Darwin had expanded his “sketch” into a 230-page “Essay”, to be expanded with his research results if he died prematurely.
(89) He was shocked in November to find many of his arguments anticipated in the anonymously published
Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, though it lacked any convincing explanation for transmutation. The book was amateurish and he scorned its geology and anatomy, but as a best-seller it widened middle-class interest in transmutation, paving the way for Darwin as well as reminding him of the need to counter all arguments.
(90) Darwin completed his third geological book in 1846, and turned in relief to dissecting and classifying the
barnacles he had collected, using his new ideas of
common descent, and the anatomy he had learnt as
Grant’s student.
(91) In 1847, Hooker read the “Essay” and sent notes that provided Darwin with the calm critical feedback that he needed, but would not commit himself and questioned Darwin’s opposition to continuing acts of
creation.
(92)In an attempt to improve his chronic ill health, Darwin went in 1849 to Dr.
James Gully’s
Malvern spa and was surprised to find some benefit from
hydrotherapy.
(93) Then in 1851 his treasured daughter
Annie fell ill, reawakening his fears that his illness might be hereditary. After a long series of crises, she died and Darwin’s faith in Christianity dwindled away.
(94)In eight years of work on barnacles (
Cirripedia), Darwin found “
homologies” that supported his theory by showing that slightly changed body parts could serve different functions to meet new conditions.
(95) In 1853 it earned him the
Royal Society’s Royal Medal, and it made his reputation as a
biologist.
(96) He resumed work on his theory of species in 1854, and in November realised that divergence in the character of descendants could be explained by them becoming adapted to “diversified places in the economy of nature”.
(97)Publication of the theory of natural selection
{{details|Publication of Darwin's theory}}
missing image!
- Charles Darwin.jpg -
Darwin was forced into swift publication of his theory of natural selection.
By the start of 1856, Darwin was investigating whether eggs and
seeds could survive travel across seawater to spread species across oceans.
Hooker increasingly doubted the traditional view that species were fixed, but their young friend
Thomas Henry Huxley was firmly against evolution.
Lyell was intrigued by Darwin’s speculations without realising their extent. When he read a paper by
Alfred Russel Wallace on the
Introduction of species, he saw similarities with Darwin’s thoughts and urged him to publish to establish precedence. Though Darwin saw no threat, he began work on a short paper. Finding answers to difficult questions held him up repeatedly, and he expanded his plans to a “big book on species” titled
Natural Selection. He continued his researches,
obtaining information and specimens from naturalists worldwide including Wallace who was working in
Borneo. In December 1857, Darwin received a letter from Wallace asking if the book would examine human origins. He responded that he would avoid that subject, “so surrounded with prejudices”, while encouraging Wallace’s theorising and adding that “I go much further than you.”
(98)Darwin’s book was half way when, on 18 June 1858, he received a paper from Wallace describing natural selection. Shocked that he had been “forestalled”, Darwin sent it on to Lyell, as requested, and, though Wallace had not asked for publication, he suggested he would send it to any journal that Wallace chose. His family was in crisis with children in the village dying of
scarlet fever, and he put matters in the hands of Lyell and Hooker. They decided on a joint presentation at the
Linnean Society on 1 July of
On the Tendency of Species to form Varieties; and on the Perpetuation of Varieties and Species by Natural Means of Selection; however, Darwin’s baby son died of the scarlet fever and he was too distraught to attend.
(99)There was little immediate attention to this announcement of the theory; after the paper was published in the August journal of the society, it was reprinted in several magazines and there were some reviews and letters, but the president of the Linnean remarked in May 1859 that the year had not been marked by any revolutionary discoveries.
(100) Only one review rankled enough for Darwin to recall it later; Professor
Samuel Haughton of Dublin claimed that “all that was new in them was false, and what was true was old.”
(101) Darwin struggled for thirteen months to produce an abstract of his “big book”, suffering from ill health but getting constant encouragement from his scientific friends. Lyell arranged to have it published by
John Murray.
(102)On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection, or The Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life (usually abbreviated to
On the Origin of Species) proved unexpectedly popular, with the entire stock of 1,250 copies oversubscribed when it went on sale to booksellers on 22 November 1859.
(103) In the book, Darwin set out “one long argument” of detailed observations, inferences and consideration of anticipated objections.
(104) His only allusion to human evolution was the understatement that “light will be thrown on the origin of man and his history”.
(105) His theory is simply stated in the introduction:{{quotation|As many more individuals of each species are born than can possibly survive; and as, consequently, there is a frequently recurring struggle for existence, it follows that any being, if it vary however slightly in any manner profitable to itself, under the complex and sometimes varying conditions of life, will have a better chance of surviving, and thus be
naturally selected. From the strong principle of inheritance, any selected variety will tend to propagate its new and modified form.
(106)}}He put a strong case for
common descent, but avoided the then controversial term “
evolution”, and at the end of the book concluded that; {{quotation|There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.
(107) }}
missing image!
- Darwin ape.jpg -
As "Darwinism" became widely accepted in the 1870s, amusing cariacatures of him with an ape or monkey body symbolised evolution.(108)
Reaction to the publication
{{details|Reaction to Darwin's theory}}Darwin’s book sparked off international debate, though the heat of controversy was less than that over earlier works such as
Vestiges of Creation.
(109) He monitored the debate closely, keeping press cuttings of
reviews,
articles,
satires,
parodies and
caricatures.
(110) Darwin had carefully said no more than "Light will be thrown on the origin of man",
(111) but the first review claimed it made a creed of the “men from monkeys” idea from
Vestiges.
(112) Amongst favourable responses were Huxley’s reviews which included swipes at
Richard Owen, leader of the scientific establishment Huxley was trying to overthrow, and when Owen's review appeared it joined those that condemned the book.
(113)The
Church of England scientific establishment, including Darwin’s old Cambridge tutors
Sedgwick and
Henslow, reacted against the book, though it was well received by
liberal clergymen who interpreted natural selection as an instrument of God's design, with the cleric
Charles Kingsley seeing it as "just as noble a conception of Deity".
(114) In 1860, the publication of
Essays and Reviews by seven liberal Anglican theologians diverted
clerical attention from Darwin, with its ideas including
higher criticism attacked by church authorities as
heresy. It included
Baden Powell's argument that
miracles broke God’s laws, so belief in them was
atheistic, and his praise for “Mr Darwin’s masterly volume [supporting] the grand principle of the self-evolving powers of nature”.
(115)The most famous confrontation took place at the public
1860 Oxford evolution debate during a meeting of the
British Association for the Advancement of Science. Professor
John William Draper delivered a long lecture about Darwin and social progress. The
Bishop of Oxford Samuel Wilberforce, who was not opposed to
transmutation, then argued against Darwin's explanation. In the ensuing debate
Joseph Hooker argued strongly for Darwin and
Thomas Huxley established himself as “Darwin’s bulldog” – the fiercest defender of evolutionary theory on the Victorian stage. Both sides came away feeling victorious, but Huxley went on to make much of his claim that on being asked by Wilberforce whether he was descended from monkeys on his grandfather’s side or his grandmother’s side, Huxley muttered: “The Lord has delivered him into my hands” and replied that he “would rather be descended from an ape than from a cultivated man who used his gifts of culture and eloquence in the service of prejudice and falsehood”.
(116) Huxley portrayed a polarisation between religion and science and used
Darwinism to campaign against the authority of the clergy in education.
(117) In Britain, friends including Hooker
(118) and
Lyell(119) took part in the scientific debates which Huxley pugnaciously led to overturn the dominance of clergymen and aristocratic amateurs under Owen in favour of a new generation of professional scientists. Owen mistakenly claimed certain anatomical differences between ape and
human brains, and accused Huxley of advocating “Ape Origin of Man”. Huxley gladly did just that, and his campaign over two years was devastatingly successful in ousting Owen and the “old guard”.
(120) Darwin’s friends formed
The X Club and helped to gain him the honour of the
Royal Society’s Copley Medal in 1864.
(121) Darwin’s theory also resonated with various movements at the time{{Ref_label|C|III|none}} and became a key fixture of popular culture.{{Ref_label|D|IV|none}}
Descent of Man, sexual selection, and botany
Despite repeated bouts of illness during the last twenty-two years of his life, Darwin pressed on with his work. He had published
On the Origin of Species as an
abstract of his theory, but more controversial aspects of his “big book” were still incomplete, including his views on humankind’s descent from earlier animals, and possible causes underlying the development of society and of human mental abilities. He had yet to explain features with decorative beauty but no obvious utility. His experiments, research and writing continued.When Darwin’s daughter fell ill, he set aside his experiments with seedlings and domestic animals to accompany her to a seaside resort where he became interested in wild
orchids. This developed into an innovative study of how their beautiful flowers served to control insect
pollination and ensure
cross fertilisation. As with the barnacles, homologous parts served different functions in different species. Back at home, he lay on his sickbed in a room filled with experiments on
climbing plants. Visitors included
Ernst Haeckel who had spread a version of
Darwinismus in Germany.
(122) Wallace remained supportive, though he increasingly turned to
Spiritualism.
(123)The first part of Darwin's planned “big book”,
Variation of Plants and Animals Under Domestication, grew to two huge volumes, forcing him to leave out
human evolution and
sexual selection. It sold briskly in 1868 despite its size, but interest tailed off.
(124) He wrote most of a second section on natural selection, but it remained unpublished in his lifetime.
(125)missing image!
- Man is But a Worm.jpg -
Punch's almanac for 1882, published shortly before Darwin’s death, depicts him amidst evolution from chaos to Victorian gentleman with the title Man Is But A Worm.
In 1863
Lyell's Geological Evidences of the Antiquity of Man had popularised prehistory, though his caution on evolution disappointed Darwin. Weeks later
Huxley's Evidence as to Man's Place in Nature had shown that anatomically humans are apes, and both books had enormous influence.
(126) With
The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex published in 1871, Darwin set out evidence from numerous sources that humans are animals, showing continuity of physical and mental attributes, and presented
sexual selection to explain impractical animal features such as the
peacock's plumage as well as human evolution of
culture, differences between sexes, and physical and cultural
racial characteristics, while emphasising that humans are all one species.
(127) His research using images was expanded in his 1872 book
The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, one of the first books to feature printed photographs, which discussed the
evolution of human psychology and its continuity with the
behaviour of animals. Both books proved very popular, and Darwin was impressed by the general assent with which his views had been received, remarking that "everybody is talking about it without being shocked."
(128) His conclusion was "that man with all his noble qualities, with sympathy which feels for the most debased, with benevolence which extends not only to other men but to the humblest living creature, with his god-like intellect which has penetrated into the movements and constitution of the solar system–with all these exalted powers–Man still bears in his bodily frame the indelible stamp of his lowly origin.”
(129)His evolution-related experiments and investigations culminated in books on the movement of climbing plants,
insectivorous plants, the effects of
cross and
self fertilisation of plants, different forms of flowers on plants of the same species, and
The Power of Movement in Plants. In his last book, he returned to the effect
earthworms have on soil formation.He died in Downe,
Kent, England, on 19 April 1882. He had expected to be buried in St Mary’s churchyard at Downe, but at the request of Darwin’s colleagues,
William Spottiswoode (President of the
Royal Society) arranged for Darwin to be given a
state funeral and buried in
Westminster Abbey, close to
John Herschel and
Isaac Newton.
(130) Only five non-royal personages were granted that honour of a UK state funeral during the 19th century.
(131) Despite his fears, most of the surviving children went on to have distinguished careers as notable members of the prominent
Darwin-Wedgwood family.
(132)Of his surviving children,
George,
Francis and
Horace became Fellows of the Royal Society, distinguished as
astronomer,
(133) botanist and
civil engineer, respectively.
(134) His son
Leonard, on the other hand, went on to be a
soldier,
politician,
economist,
eugenicist and mentor of the statistician and evolutionary biologist
Ronald Fisher.
(135)Religious views
{{Details|Charles Darwin's views on religion}}Though Charles Darwin’s family background was
Nonconformist, and his father, grandfather and brother were
Freethinkers,
(136) at first he did not doubt the
literal truth of the
Bible.
(137) He attended a
Church of England school, then at Cambridge studied
Anglican theology to become a clergyman.
(138) He was convinced by
William Paley’s
teleological argument that design in nature proved the
existence of God,
(139) but during the
Beagle voyage he questioned, for example, why deep-ocean
plankton had been created with so much beauty for little purpose as no one could see them,
(140) or the
problem of evil of how the
ichneumon wasp paralysing
caterpillars as live food for its eggs could be reconciled with Paley’s vision of beneficent design.
(141) He was still quite
orthodox and would quote the Bible as an authority on
morality, but was
critical of the history in the
Old Testament.
(142)missing image!
- Annie Darwin.jpg -
frame|The 1851 death of Darwin’s daughter, Annie, marked the end of his dwindling faith in Christianity.
When investigating
transmutation of species he knew that his naturalist friends thought this a bestial heresy undermining miraculous justifications for the social order, the kind of
radical argument then being used by
Dissenters and
atheists to attack the Church of England’s privileged position as the
established church.
(143) Though Darwin wrote of religion as a
tribal survival strategy, he still believed that God was the ultimate lawgiver.
(144) His belief dwindled, and his grief at the death of his daughter
Annie in 1851 made him more certain in his scepticism.
(145) He continued to help the local church with parish work, but on Sundays would go for a walk while his family attended church.
(146) He now thought it better to look at pain and suffering as the result of general laws rather than direct intervention by God.
(147) When asked about his religious views, he wrote that he had never been an atheist in the sense of denying the existence of a God, and that generally “an
Agnostic would be the more correct description of my state of mind.”
(148)The “
Lady Hope Story”, published in 1915, claimed that Darwin had reverted back to Christianity on his sickbed. The claims were refuted by Darwin’s children and have been dismissed as false by historians.
(149) His daughter, Henrietta, who was at his deathbed, said that he did not convert to Christianity.
(150) His last words were, in fact, directed at Emma:
“Remember what a good wife you have been.”(151)Political interpretations
missing image!
- Charles Darwin 1871.jpg -
Caricature from 1871 Vanity Fair
Darwin’s theories and writings, combined with
Gregor Mendel’s
genetics (the “
modern synthesis”), form the basis of all modern biology.
(152) However, Darwin’s fame and popularity led to his name being associated with ideas and movements which at times had only an indirect relation to his writings, and sometimes went directly against his express comments.
Eugenics
{{details|Eugenics}}Darwin was interested by his
half-cousin Francis Galton's argument, introduced in 1865, that
statistical analysis of
heredity showed that moral and mental human traits could be inherited, and principles of animal breeding could apply to humans. In
The Descent of Man Darwin noted that aiding the weak to survive and have families could lose the benefits of
natural selection, but cautioned that withholding such aid would endanger the instinct of sympathy, "the noblest part of our nature", and factors such as education could be more important. When Galton suggested that publishing research could encourage intermarriage within a "caste" of "those who are naturally gifted", Darwin foresaw practical difficulties, and thought it "the sole feasible, yet I fear
utopian, plan of procedure in improving the human race", preferring to simply publicise the importance of inheritance and leave decisions to individuals.
(153) Galton named the field of study
Eugenics in 1883, after Darwin’s death, and developed
biometrics. Eugenics movements were widespread at a time when Darwin's
natural selection was eclipsed by
Mendelian genetics, and in some countries including the United States
compulsory sterilisation laws in were imposed.
Nazi eugenics in
Germany discredited the idea.{{Ref_label|E|V|none}}
Social Darwinism
{{details|Social Darwinism}}The ideas of
Thomas Malthus and
Herbert Spencer which applied ideas of evolution and “
survival of the fittest” to societies, nations and businesses became popular in the late 19th and early 20th century, and were used to defend various, sometimes contradictory, ideological perspectives including
laissez-faire economics,
(154) colonialism,
(155) racism and
imperialism.
(156) The term “Social Darwinism” originated around the 1890s, but became popular as a derogatory term in the 1940s with
Richard Hofstadter’s critique of laissez-faire conservatism.
(157) The concepts predate Darwin’s publication of the
Origin in 1859:
(158) Darwin himself insisted that social policy should not simply be guided by concepts of struggle and selection in nature.
(159) He did not share the racism common at his time, and was strongly against slavery, against "ranking the so-called races of man as distinct species", and against ill-treatment of native people.{{Ref_label|F|VI|none}}
Commemoration
missing image!
- Charles Darwin 1880.jpg -
frame|Darwin in 1880, still working on his contributions to evolutionary thought that had had an enormous effect on many fields of science.
During Darwin’s lifetime, many species and geographical features were given his name. An expanse of water adjoining the
Beagle Channel was named
Darwin Sound by
Robert FitzRoy after Darwin’s prompt action, along with two or three of the men, saved them from being marooned on a nearby shore when a collapsing
glacier caused a large wave that would have swept away their boats,
(160) and the nearby
Mount Darwin in the
Andes was named in celebration of Darwin’s 25th birthday.
(161) When the
Beagle was surveying Australia in 1839, Darwin’s friend
John Lort Stokes sighted a natural harbour which the ship’s captain
Wickham named
Port Darwin.
(162) The settlement of
Palmerston founded there in 1869 was officially renamed
Darwin in 1911. It became the capital city of Australia’s
Northern Territory,
(163) and
Charles Darwin National Park.
(164) Darwin College, Cambridge, founded in 1964, was named in honour of the Darwin family, partially because they owned some of the land it was on.
(165)The 14 species of
finches he collected in the
Galápagos Islands are affectionately named “
Darwin’s finches” in honour of his legacy.
(166) In 1992, Darwin was ranked #16 on
Michael H. Hart’s
list of the most influential figures in history.
(167) Darwin came fourth in the
100 Greatest Britons poll sponsored by the
BBC and voted for by the public.
(168) In 2000 Darwin’s image appeared on the
Bank of England ten pound note, replacing
Charles Dickens. His impressive, luxuriant beard (which was reportedly difficult to forge) was said to be a contributory factor to the bank’s choice.
(169)The
Linnean Society of London has commemorated Darwin's achievements by the award of the
Darwin-Wallace Medal since 1908.As a humorous celebration of evolution, the annual
Darwin Award is bestowed on individuals who “improve our gene pool by removing themselves from it.”
(170)Numerous biographies of Darwin have been written, and the 1980 biographical novel
The Origin by
Irving Stone gives a closely researched fictional account of Darwin’s life from the age of 22 onwards.Darwin has been the subject of many exhibitions, including the “Darwin” exhibition, which opened at the
American Museum of Natural History in
New York City in 2006, traveled to the
Field Museum in
Chicago, is currently being hosted by The
Royal Ontario Museum in
Toronto and will open in London in late 2009.
(171) The exhibit is part of a series of events celebrating the bicentenary of Darwin's birth and the 150th anniversary of the publication of the
Origin of Species. Other celebrations include a festival at the
University of Cambridge in July 2009, and "Darwin200," a series of events hosted by various British organizations under the auspices of London's
Natural History Museum. In September 2008, the
Church of England issued an article saying that the 200th anniversary of his birth was a fitting time to apologise to Darwin for "for misunderstanding you and, by getting our first reaction wrong, encouraging others to misunderstand you still".
(172).
Works
{{details|List of works by Charles Darwin}}Darwin was a prolific author, and even without publication of his works on evolution would have had a considerable reputation as the author of
The Voyage of the Beagle, as a geologist who had published extensively on
South America and had solved the puzzle of the formation of
coral atolls, and as a biologist who had published the definitive work on
barnacles. While
The Origin of Species dominates perceptions of his work,
The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex and
The Expression of Emotions in Man and Animals had considerable impact, and his books on plants including
The Power of Movement in Plants were innovative studies of great importance, as was his final work on
The Formation of Vegetable Mould Through the Action of Worms.
(173){{botanist|Darwin|Darwin, Charles}}
See also
Notes
I. {{Note_label|A|I|none}} Darwin was eminent as a
naturalist,
geologist,
biologist, and
author; after working as a physician’s assistant and two years as a
medical student was educated as a
clergyman; and was trained in
taxidermy.
II. {{Note_label|B|II|none}}
Robert FitzRoy was to become known after the voyage for biblical literalism, but at this time he had considerable interest in Lyell’s ideas, and they met before the voyage when Lyell asked for observations to be made in South America. FitzRoy’s diary during the ascent of the River Santa Cruz in
Patagonia recorded his opinion that the plains were
raised beaches, but on return, newly married to a very religious lady, he recanted these ideas. {{Harv|Browne|1995|pp= 186, 414}}
III. {{Note_label|C|III|none}} See, for example, WILLA volume 4,
Charlotte Perkins Gilman and the Feminization of Education by Deborah M. De Simone: “Gilman shared many basic educational ideas with the generation of thinkers who matured during the period of “intellectual chaos” caused by Darwin’s Origin of the Species. Marked by the belief that individuals can direct human and social evolution, many progressives came to view education as the panacea for advancing social progress and for solving such problems as urbanisation, poverty, or immigration.”
IV. {{Note_label|D|IV|none}} See, for example, the song “A lady fair of lineage high” from
Gilbert and Sullivan’s
Princess Ida, which describes the descent of man (but not woman!) from apes.
V. {{Note_label|E|V|none}}
Geneticists studied human heredity as
Mendelian inheritance, while
eugenics movements sought to manage society, with a focus on
social class in the United Kingdom, and on disability and ethnicity in the United States, leading to geneticists seeing this as impractical
pseudoscience. A shift from voluntary arrangements to "negative" eugenics included
compulsory sterilisation laws in the United States, copied by
Nazi Germany as the basis for
Nazi eugenics based on virulent racism and "
racial hygiene".
({{Citation
| last = Thurtle
| first =Phillip
| publication-date =
| date =Updated December 17, 1996
| title =the creation of genetic identity
| periodical =SEHR
| volume = 5
| issue =Supplement: Cultural and Technological Incubations of Fascism
| url =http://www.stanford.edu/group/SHR/5-supp/text/thurtle.html
| accessdate =2008-11-11 }}
{{Citation
| last = Edwards
| first =A. W. F.
| year = 2000
| title =The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection
| periodical = Genetics
| volume = 154
| issue =April 2000
| pages = 1419-1426
| url =http://www.genetics.org/cgi/content/full/154/4/1419#The_Eclipse_of_Darwinism
| accessdate =2008-11-11 }}
WEB
, Wilkins
, John
, Evolving Thoughts: Darwin and the Holocaust 3: eugenics
,
weblink , 2008-11-11, )
VI. {{Note_label|F|VI|none}} Darwin did not share the then common view that other races are inferior, and regarded his
taxidermy tutor
John Edmonstone, a freed black slave, as a "very pleasant and intelligent man".
[ Early in the Beagle voyage he nearly lost his position on the ship when he criticised FitzRoy's defence and praise of slavery. {{Harv|Darwin||p=74}} He wrote home about "how steadily the general feeling, as shown at elections, has been rising against Slavery. What a proud thing for England if she is the first European nation which utterly abolishes it! I was told before leaving England that after living in slave countries all my opinions would be altered; the only alteration I am aware of is forming a much higher estimate of the negro character." {{harv|Darwin|1887|p=246}} Regarding Fuegians, he "could not have believed how wide was the difference between savage and civilized man: it is greater than between a wild and domesticated animal, inasmuch as in man there is a greater power of improvement", but he knew and liked civilised Fuegians like Jemmy Button: "It seems yet wonderful to me, when I think over all his many good qualities, that he should have been of the same race, and doubtless partaken of the same character, with the miserable, degraded savages whom we first met here. {{Harv|Darwin|1845|pp= 205, 207–208}} In the Descent of Man he mentioned the Fuegians and Edmonstone when arguing against "ranking the so-called races of man as distinct species".][ He rejected the ill-treatment of native people, and for example wrote of massacres of Patagonian men, women, and children, "Every one here is fully convinced that this is the most just war, because it is against barbarians. Who would believe in this age that such atrocities could be committed in a Christian civilized country?" {{harv|Darwin|1845|p-102}}] Citations
-
[ The fact that evolution occurs became accepted by the scientific community and the general public in his lifetime, while his theory of natural selection came to be widely seen as the primary explanation of the process of evolution in the 1930s,][{{Harvnb|van Wyhe|2008}}.]
-
[The Complete Works of Darwin Online - Biography. darwin-online.org.uk. Retrieved on 2006-12-15.]
{{Harvnb|Dobzhansky|1973}}
-
[{{Harvnb|Leff|2000}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 210, 263–274, 284–285}}.]
-
[{{harvnb|van Wyhe|2007|p=184, 187}}]
-
[Darwin - At last. American Museum of Natural History. Retrieved on 2007-03-21.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Freeman|1977}}]
-
[WEB,weblink BBC NEWS : Politics : Thatcher state funeral undecided, 2008-08-02, 2008-08-10, ]
-
[WEB,weblink AboutDarwin.com - Darwin's Burial, 2008-03-02, 2008-02-10, ]
-
[The Mount House, Shrewsbury, England (Charles Darwin), Baruch College - Darwin and Darwinism. Retrieved on 2006-12-15.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 12–15}}.]
-
[{{harvnb|Darwin|1958|p=51.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1871|pp=214, 232.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p=72}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p=82}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p=33–40}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p=42–43}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 47–48}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1887|p=60}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1887|pp=62–67}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1887|p=59.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p=97}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|von Sydow|2005}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1887|p=67–68.}}]
{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|pp=128–129, 133–141}}.
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 94–97}}.]
-
[{{harvnb|keynes|2000|pp=ix–xi.}}]
-
[ He kept careful notes of his observations and theoretical speculations, and at intervals during the voyage his specimens were sent to Cambridge together with letters including a copy of his journal for his family.][{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 189–192, 198}}.]
-
[WEB,weblink Darwin's field notes on the Galapagos: 'A little world within itself', Gordon Chancellor, Randal Keynes, October, 2006, Darwin Online, ]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|pp=177–178}}.]
-
[On their first stop ashore at St Jago, Darwin found that a white band high in the volcanic rock cliffs included seashells. FitzRoy had given him the first volume of Charles Lyell’s Principles of Geology which set out uniformitarian concepts of land slowly rising or falling over immense periods,{{Ref_label|B|II|none}} and Darwin saw things Lyell's way, theorising and thinking of writing a book on geology.][{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|pp=183–190}}]
-
[{{harvnb|Keynes|2001|pp=41–42.}}]
-
[{{harvnb|Darwin|1958|pp=73–74.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p= 223–235}}]
{{Harvnb|Darwin|1835|p=7}}
{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 210}}
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 189–192, 198}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Eldredge|2006}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 131, 159}}]
{{harvnb|Herbert|1991|pp=174–179.}}
-
[WEB,weblink Darwin Online: 'Hurrah Chiloe': an introduction to the Port Desire Notebook, 2008-10-24, ]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1845|pp= 205–208}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p= 244–250}}]
-
[{{harvnb|Keynes|2001|p=226–227.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 160–168, 182}}.]
{{Harvnb|Darwin|1887|p= 260}}.
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1958|loc=p 98–99}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Eldredge|2006}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 145, 170–172}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1839|p=526}}.]
-
[{{harvnb|Keynes|2001|pp=398–399.}}]
-
[ FitzRoy began writing the official Narrative of the Beagle voyages, and after reading Darwin’s diary he proposed incorporating it into the account.][WEB,weblink Darwin Correspondence Project - Letter 301 — Darwin, C. R. to Darwin, C. S., 29 Apr 1836, ]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p= 336}}]
-
[WEB,weblink Darwin Online: 'Runaway Rascals': an introduction to the Despoblado Notebook, 2008-10-24, ]
-
[{{Harvnb|Keynes|2000}}]
{{Harvnb|Eldredge|2006}}
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1859|loc=p. 1}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Darwin|1835|loc= editorial introduction.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 195–198}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Owen|1840|loc=No. 1 p 16 No.3 p 73 No. 4 p 106}}]
{{Harvnb|Eldredge|2006}}.
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 201–205}}.]
{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p=349–350}}.
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p= 345–347}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 207–210}}.]
{{Harvnb|Sulloway|1982|p=57}}
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 196–201, 212–221}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 220–221}}.]
-
[{{harvnb|Herbert|1980|p=7–9.}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 229–232}}.]
{{Harvnb|van Wyhe|2008}}.
{{Harvnb|Eldredge|2006}}.
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|pp=367–369}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 233–234}}.]
{{Harvnb|Arrhenius|1921|pp=255–257}}
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 233–236}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 241–244, 426}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Browne|1995|p=xii}}]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 241–244}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Desmond|Moore|1991|p= 252}}.]
-
[{{Harvnb|Gordon|Ref=CITEREFGordonThomas1999|1999}}.]
- <